To step into the poetry of Mary Szybist is to enter a space of ‘incarnadine’ and ‘Mary-blue.’ It is a world where the sacred is not something distant or dusty, but a lived, breathing, and often unsettling presence. Born in Williamsport, Pennsylvania, in 1970, Szybist grew up in the literal shadow of religious icons. Each week at the Church of the Annunciation, she looked up at Tiffany stained-glass windows that shifted with the afternoon light. It was here that her lifelong obsession with the figure of Mary—her namesake—began.
A Philosophy of Patience
For poets and poetry lovers, Szybist represents a rare kind of patience. She is not a poet of the rapid-fire collection; her first book, 'Granted,' arrived in 2003, and it would be another ten years before her landmark second book, 'Incarnadine,' took the literary world by storm, winning the National Book Award in 2013. That gap reflects her philosophy of the craft: she describes poetry as a ‘halting place’ on a larger spiritual journey, a practice of deep listening that cannot be rushed.
Fierce Fragility and Musicality
Her style is characterized by what critic Kay Ryan called a ‘lovely musical touch’ that is ‘light and exact enough to catch the weight and grind of love.’ Szybist is a master of the ‘fierce fragility.’ She often explores the permeable barrier between the spirit and the body, motherhood and childlessness. In her first book, 'Granted,' she established this tension in the poem 'In Tennessee I Found a Firefly,' where she writes:
"There is courtship, and there is hunger. I suppose there are grips from which even angels cannot fly. Even imagined ones."
Formal Fearlessness
Innovation in Szybist's work is found in her formal fearlessness. She does not just write in stanzas; she builds structures. 'Incarnadine' is famous for its experimental forms, including a poem composed as a diagrammed sentence and a concrete poem where lines radiate from a circular void like the rays of a sun. Perhaps most striking are her ‘Annunciations.’ Szybist spent time in Florence, Italy, becoming overwhelmed by how many Renaissance paintings depicted the angel Gabriel’s visit to the Virgin Mary. She began to wonder how those limitations of subject could actually unlock a profusion of meaning.
She reimagines the Annunciation in dozens of ways: as a scene from the perspective of the grass beneath the figures, or through the lens of a 21st-century scandal using text from the Starr Report. In 'Annunciation (from the grass beneath them),' she captures the uncanny intimacy of the moment:
"even the shadows her chin made / never touched but reached just passed the crushed mint, / the clover clustered between us / how cool would you say it was"
Finding the Spectacular
If you are coming to Szybist for the first time, start with the poem 'The Lushness of It.' It is a breathtaking entry point because it encapsulates her core mission: to remain curious and to refuse the boredom of the modern world. In this poem, she encourages us to give ourselves permission to ‘write out of nothing other than an interest in listening.’ It is an invitation to witness the world with the same intensity she does—one where the flash of a bird or the shadow on a wall is a potential message from the divine.
Szybist, who now teaches at Lewis & Clark College in Portland, continues to be a compass for those of us who find faith complicated and desire even more so. She reminds us that the spectacular is never behind us; it is in the very air we breathe. As she writes in the closing of 'The Troubadours, Etc.':
"Just for this evening, won’t you put me before you until I’m far enough away you can believe in me? Then try, try to come closer— my wonderful and less than."
Backgrounder Notes
As an expert researcher and library scientist, I have identified several key terms and concepts within the article that provide essential context for understanding Mary Szybist’s work. Below are the backgrounders for these items:
Marian Blue (Mary-blue)
In Western art and Christian iconography, this specific shade of deep blue has been the traditional color of the Virgin Mary’s mantle since the 5th century. Historically produced from the expensive semi-precious stone lapis lazuli, the color symbolizes purity, divinity, and Mary's status as the Queen of Heaven.
Incarnadine
Derived from the Latin caro (flesh), this term refers to a bright crimson or pinkish-red color. While it famously appears in Shakespeare’s Macbeth to describe blood, Szybist uses it to explore the "incarnation"—the theological concept of the divine taking on human flesh and the messy, physical reality of the body.
Tiffany Stained-Glass
Created by Louis Comfort Tiffany’s studios in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, these windows are renowned for using "opalescent" glass to create painterly textures and depth without the use of paint. Their presence in Szybist’s childhood church represents a specific American aesthetic of spiritual light and decorative craftsmanship.
The National Book Award for Poetry
Established in 1950, this is one of the most prestigious literary honors in the United States, awarded annually by the National Book Foundation to celebrate the year’s best work by an American citizen. Szybist’s 2013 win for Incarnadine solidified her position as a central figure in contemporary American letters.
The Annunciation
In Christian theology and art history, this refers to the moment the Archangel Gabriel announces to the Virgin Mary that she will conceive the son of God. It is one of the most common motifs in Western art, representing the precise threshold where the spiritual world intersects with the physical world.
Sentence Diagramming
This is a visual method of breaking down the grammatical structure of a sentence—typically using the Reed-Kellogg system—to show the relationship between subjects, verbs, and modifiers. Szybist utilizes this pedagogical tool as a poetic form to "map" the complex logic of faith and language.
Concrete Poetry
Also known as "shape poetry," this is a genre where the visual arrangement of words on the page is as essential to the meaning as the text itself. In Szybist’s work, the physical layout of the poem serves as a structural metaphor for the subjects she explores, such as sunlight or emptiness.
The Starr Report
Released in 1998 by Independent Counsel Kenneth Starr, this was a highly controversial official investigation into President Bill Clinton’s conduct. By repurposing its clinical, legalistic language in a poem about the Annunciation, Szybist creates a "found text" collage that explores themes of power, exposure, and public scandal.
The Italian Renaissance
A period of intense cultural and artistic "rebirth" (14th–16th centuries) centered in cities like Florence, where artists like Fra Angelico and Botticelli perfected the imagery of the Annunciation. Szybist’s time in Florence allowed her to study how these historical depictions could be deconstructed and reimagined for a modern audience.
Sources
-
substack.comhttps://joansowhat.substack.com/p/incarnadine-by-mary-szybist-poetry-book
-
substack.comhttps://ordinaryplots.substack.com/p/mary-szybists-the-lushness-of-it
-
poets.orghttps://poets.org/poem/all-times-and-all-tenses-moment
-
rosemaryandreadingglasses.comhttps://rosemaryandreadingglasses.com/2014/02/17/recommended-reading-incarnadine-by-mary-szybist/